RITZVILLE, Wash. — The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is allowing a civil rights lawsuit against two Adams County sheriff’s deputies over warrantless entries into a home and the seizure of a woman’s cellphone to move forward.
The case involves deputies Saul Chavez and Sgt. Juan Garcia, who Chauna and Andrew Carlson are suing over an October 2022 incident at their Ritzville home. The Carlsons allege the deputies violated their constitutional rights by entering their residence without a warrant and taking Chauna Carlson’s cellphone.
Court rejects qualified immunity.
The deputies appealed a federal district court decision denying them qualified immunity, which can protect government officials from lawsuits over actions taken in their official duties.
In a decision filed Sept. 9, the Ninth Circuit ruled that the deputies are not entitled to qualified immunity at this stage. The court said the warrantless entries violated the Fourth Amendment and no threat of evidence being destroyed existed.
The court also found that Garcia’s decision to retain Carlson’s cellphone for hours after an investigating detective from Grant County said it was not needed made the seizure unreasonable. The deputies did not attempt to obtain a warrant during that time, the court said.
The ruling allows the Carlsons’ civil rights claims under federal law to continue. It does not represent a final ruling on whether the deputies will be held liable.
Judge disputes majority’s reasoning.
Judge Richard Clifton dissented, arguing the deputies should receive qualified immunity. He said the deputies were responding to an alleged domestic violence incident and were attempting to preserve the scene for investigators from the Grant County Sheriff’s Office. Adams County asked GCSO to handle the investigation because of a perceived conflict of interest.
The Carlsons are related to Ritzville police officer Matthew Carlson, who is challenging Sheriff Dale Wagner in the upcoming general election.
Lawsuit continues
The Ninth Circuit’s decision allows the Carlsons’ civil rights claims to proceed. The ruling concerns qualified immunity and the denial of summary judgment, not a final determination of liability.
The court’s memorandum decision is not intended for publication and does not serve as binding precedent under the court’s rules.

